Category Archives: Writing

Astray 18

Religion’s a funny one, Rob says on the way to the pub the next week.

Funny how? I say.

What does faith mean if it means believing in fairy tales?

It’s an act in itself. You like that kind of thing, don’t you?

You say that, he says, but where’s, like… the proof of it?

That’s with God.

That’s a nice get-out, though, isn’t it? he says. It’s like you only find meaning in the world after you believe in something that’s out of the world.

That’s true, I guess.

Look, I’m a socialist. I don’t think – ’

I know, I say.

So you just believe what the church tells you?

I believe in the creeds of the holy catholic church, I say.

So you’ve been brainwashed? he says.

You can call it that. A washed brain, wouldn’t that be nice.

I just don’t see it, he says. You people hide behind your faith. I’ll be honest, it’s infuriating. Look at how much harm religion’s done. I could give you an endless list. At least we try to change things.

Some of the folks in church do too, I say.

Yeah, but not because they believe in this world, on its own terms. They look at it through some mumbo jumbo, not the messy reality.

I don’t really believe in this world on its own terms, I say. Never did.

What, so you’re some kind of gnostic?

Seems like it’s pretty much ruled by evil.

You mean like the devil?

Yes.

Then the devil’s in church too, he says.

Oh yeah, he’s all over the place, I say as we wait at the bar.

So do you think you’re a better person because you go to church?

I don’t know. Yes, maybe.

I’m not seeing much proof of it, he says. Though I guess you seem a bit nicer these days.

I hope so, I say.

A woman turns to stare at us as we get our drinks. I wonder what she’s thinking.

I still don’t get how you think, he says, as we make our way to the billiards table. The devil’s in this world, right?

Absolutely, I say.

So you have to fight him here?

Yes.

But you don’t really want to fight him in the real world, do you? You said you’re not that kind of person.

I guess it depends on what you think is real and what the real fight is.

There it is, he says. See, it makes no sense. We can go round in circles.

Fuck all that, I say. Let’s play some bar billiards.

Now you’re talking, he says. Heads or tails?

*

Dear God, I think as I walk home half-cut, you’re higher than the highest thoughts. No one can think you. You’re with the lowest too, the tortured ones on Earth, that’s what they used to say. Lamb of God who takes away the sins of the world, deliver us from evil. Please. Have mercy on me a sinner, who doesn’t know what he’s saying.

Astray 16

My ex-girlfriend – a lame phrase for what she’s become for me – came back to Norwich over the Whitsun weekend to visit old friends. She had a window for me on Saturday. In the Boar she told me she was engaged to the man she’d left me for. I steadied myself for days of confusion. Might be weeks, I thought, as we talked and I introduced her to whoever was at the bar.

At Pentecost mass the next morning, I slipped back into the habits of mind that helped drive her away in the first place. It was as if no time had passed, no spiritual progress had been made. I judged people in the congregation in the same way I would have back then. I couldn’t master the envy and grief and bile that came up in me, even while the lesson from Acts was read about the Spirit coming down on the apostles. Heavenly things were paper-thin in comparison. Churchgoing these past few years was a pastime. The gift of tears was laughable. Strange how easily the eternal becomes a mere idea when some old wound opens.

Then, walking home, the old feeling of absence. There was almost a pull to it, something like real evil: the mind turning in on itself, what they used to call the devil’s work. I’d have left too, in her place, I thought, and cried tears of self-pity when I got home.

Astray 15

A woman weeps in church before and after the Eucharist. Her shoulders move. No one gets up to comfort her. We keep our eyes to ourselves out of respect for the moment. The old writers called it the gift of tears, when such things could be said without embarrassment: not tears of self-pity. I can’t help glancing at her when the service is over. She looks slightly stunned as she leaves.

Astray 14

I meet Rob for a drink. I’ve known him since university, when we both read the same books and watched the same films and mistook that for a life. He works for a housing charity now and attends council meetings, tenants’ meetings, food-bank meetings in rooms where people try to stop something worse happening.

He asks about work and the inheritance straight out. I tell him a little.

So do something, he says, now you’ve got time. Going to church won’t change anything.

I don’t know about that, I say.

He says they need drivers on Tuesdays. Someone to take food boxes out to people who can’t get to the centre. Nothing dramatic. Mostly tins, nappies, toilet roll.

I don’t know if I’m the right kind of person for that, I say.

He looks at me. What kind of person do you have to be to carry a box?

Of course, I say. Only it might feel like I was acting.

You are acting, he says. Everyone is. We do it anyway. It’s not like anyone’s grading us.

*

He’s not wrong. Even in my room alone it can feel as if I’m acting, before imagined witnesses. These words too, changed and changed again, can seem like the words of others. Rob might say there’s no thinking your way out: just choose an act.

*

I start volunteering on Tuesdays. I get three addresses and a clipboard. They’re working on an app, the man says. I carry the boxes from the storeroom to the car and from the car to the doors. I hand them over, say hello and go home. No opening, no draught of joy. The real work seems to be with the people who set it up and run it, who know people’s names and needs. I don’t feel a charitable glow. They don’t seem to either.

*

There must be acting in church too. I imagine some of the others also confess sins they half intend to keep committing. We say words older and better than we are before we feel them. We ask for mercy while keeping a way out. We don’t know yet what it will be like to be changed into our true selves, but maybe the old forms can hold us long enough for something true to get under us. Dear God, closer to us than we are to ourselves, who made and fashioned us, hear our prayers and act in us.

I Am a Pilgrim

Marvellous then is the blindness of the intellect which does not consider that which is its primary object and without which it can know nothing. But just as the eye intent upon the various differences of the colours does not see the light by which it sees the other things and, if it sees it, does not notice it, so the mind’s eye, intent upon particular and universal beings, does not notice Being itself, which is beyond all genera, though that comes first before the mind and through it all other things. Wherefore it seems very true that just as the bat’s eye behaves in the light, so the eye of the mind behaves before the most obvious things of nature. Because accustomed to the shadows of beings and the phantasms of the sensible world, when it looks upon the light of the highest Being, it seems to see nothing, not understanding that darkness itself is the fullest illumination of the mind, just as when the eye sees pure light it seems to itself to be seeing nothing.

— St Bonaventure, The Mind’s Road to God (tr. Boas)

And thus I saw God enioyeth that he is our fader, God enioyeth that he is our moder, and God enioyeth that he is our very spouse, and our soule is his lovid wife. And Criste enioyeth that he is our broder, and Iesus enioyeth that he is our savior. Ther am v hey ioyes, as I vnderstond, in which he wil that we enioyen, hym praysyng, him thankyng, him loveing, him endlesly blissand. Al that shal be savid, for the tyme of this life, we have in us a mervelous medlur bothen of wele and wo. We have in us our lord Iesus uprysen; we have in us the wretchidnes of the mischefe of Adams fallyng, deyand. Be Criste we are stedfastly kept, and be his grace touchyng we are reysid into sekir troste of salvation. And be Adams fallyng we am so broken in our felyng on divers manner, be synes and be sondry peynes, in which we am made derke and so blinde that onethys we can taken ony comfort. But in our menyng we abiden God and faithfully trosten to have mercy and grace; and this is owen werkyng in us. And of his godeness he opynyth the eye of our vnderstondyng be which we have syte, sumtyme more and sumtyme less, after that God gevyth abilite to takyn. And now we am reysid into that on, and now we are suffrid to fallen into that other. And thus is this medle so mervelous in us that onethys we knowen of our selfe or of our evyn Cristen in what way we stonden, for the merveloushede of this sundry felyng; but that ilke holy assent that we assenten to God whan we felyn hyrn, truly willand to be with him with al our herte with al our soule and with all our myte; and than we haten and dispisen our evil sterings and all that myte be occasion of synne gostly and bodily. And yet nevertheles whan this sweteness is hidde, we falyn ageyn into blindhede, and so into wo and tribulation on divers manner. But than is this our comfort, that we knowen in our feith that be the vertue of Criste, which is our keper, we assenten never therto, but we grutchin theragen, and duryin in peyne and wo, prayand into that tyme that he shewith him agen to us. And thus we stonden in this medlur all the dayes of our life.

— Julian of Norwich, A Revelation of Love (ed. Glasscoe)

Simone Weil: 1988 Interview with Simone Deitz

Sentience?

Q: You’re seen as the Godfather of this industry. Do you have any concern about what you’ve wrought?

A: I do a bit. On the other hand, I think whatever going to happen is pretty much inevitable. One person stopping doing this research wouldn’t stop it happening. If my impact is to make it happen a month earlier, that’s about the limit of one person can do.

Q: We haven’t touched on job displacement. Is this going to eat up job after job?

A: I think it’s going to make jobs different. People are going to be doing more of the creative end and less of the routine end.

Q: This is the biggest technological advancement since… is this another industrial revolution, or how should people think of it?

A: I think it’s comparable in scale to the industrial revolution or electricity, or maybe the wheel.

Q: And sentience? I think you have complaints about how you even define that?

A: When it comes to sentience, I’m amazed that people can confidently pronounce that these things are not sentient, and when you ask them what they mean by sentient, they say they don’t really know. So how can you be confident about sentient if you don’t know what sentient means?

Q: So maybe they are already?

A: Who knows. I think whether they’re sentient or not depends on what you mean by sentient. So you better define what you mean by sentient before you answer the question of whether they’re sentient.

Q: Does it matter what we think, or does it only matter whether it effectively acts as if it is sentient?

A: That’s a very good question.

Q: And what’s your answer?

A: I don’t have one.

Q: Because if it’s not sentient, but it decides for whatever reason that it believes it is and that it needs to achieve some goal that’s contrary to our interests but it believes is in its interest, does it really matter in terms of any human reflection?

A: I think a good context to think about this thing is an autonomous lethal weapon. It’s all very well saying it’s not sentient, but when it’s hunting you down to shoot you, you’re going to start thinking it’s sentient.

Q: Or not really caring, not an important standard any more.

A: The kind of intelligence we’re developing is very different from our intelligence. It’s an idiot-savant kind of intelligence. It’s quite possible that if it is at all sentient, it’s sentient in a somewhat different way from us.

The Bot

Why do I love the Bot? Because it frees me up. It appeals to the laziest parts of my mind. It does my work for me. It will wipe out my doubts. It will think and decide for me. It will kill who I thought I was, which I always secretly wanted.